Rivalry Weekend
College football introduced “Rivalry Weekend” decades ago, a slate of games that features “The Game” between Ohio State and Michigan. Since MLB introduced interleague play in 1997, baseball now has a Rivalry Weekend as well. Last weekend (May 16-18), we were treated to some storied matchups and a few, somewhat contrived. Let’s take a look at the best of them:
Subway Series (Mets vs. Yankees). The origin of the NYC rivalries goes back to the days of the Brooklyn Dodgers, New York Giants, and New York Yankees. When the two NL teams moved to LA and San Francisco in 1958, the Yankees reigned. The expansion Mets arrived in 1962, and the “Mayor’s Trophy Game”, an in-season exhibition game, was played by the teams until the early 1980s. In 2000, the first Subway Series in the World Series since 1956 (when the Yankees played the Dodgers) captured the Big Apple. While the Yanks defeated the Mets in five games, it was not without some intrigue, including a bench-clearing incident in Game 2. Today, both teams are near the top of their respective leagues in the won-loss column. We could see a rematch in 2025. A week ago, the Yankees took the three-game set 2 games to 1, and remain in control of the all-time series, 86-68.
Crosstown Classic (Cubs vs. White Sox). This inter-city series has gone by a lot of names. My preference is North Siders vs. South Siders. The teams have met in the World Series only one time, in 1906, won by the White Sox “Hitless Wonders” in six games. In 1985, the teams began an annual “Windy City Classic” exhibition game. The most famous exhibition game was played at Wrigley in 1994, when the White Sox invited Michael Jordan from its AA-affiliate Birmingham Barons team to join the fun. It is truly a heated rivalry, featuring fisticuffs and a brawl in 2006. A week ago, the Cubbies swept the Sox in ugly fashion and now lead the all-time series, 76-75. Pope Leo XIV need not worry about a potential conflict this year. While the Cubs have their sights set on the 2025 World Series, the South Siders have no such expectations.
Freeway Series (Dodgers vs. Angels). The first series between the teams began as exhibition contests in 1962. While the teams of course are matched as rivals now with the advent of interleague play, the exhibition series is still intact. Each season between the end of the Cactus League and Opening Day, the teams play in their respective ballparks in LA and Anaheim. For the Angels, the biggest issue has always been what to name them. The Dodgers have tried to block a simple reference to Los Angeles. So the Angels have been the California Angels, Anaheim Angels, and the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim. The 2002 World Series is thought of as the Angels ultimate revenge when they faced off against the Dodgers’ bitter rivals, the Giants. The Angels won their first and only world championship. The Angels lead the regular season series, 78-73, coming off their recent 3-game sweep.
Bay Bridge Series (Giants vs. Athletics). This series has certainly lost its luster with the Athletics move to Sacramento and ultimately to Vegas. Interestingly, it’s been always thought of as a friendly one even though both teams resided in the same metropolitan area. If you would ask baseball fans in the Bay Area about their MLB rooting interest, you might often get the response that they like both teams. The 1989 World Series was the first and only time the teams met in championship play. Yet, what happened on the playing surface, a sweep by the Athletics, was of lesser importance than seeing how the community came together in the aftermath of the October 17, 1989, earthquake. The Series was suspended and resumed 10 days later. Most recently, the Giants got a sweep of their own which tightened the all-time series at Athletics 76 wins, SF 75.
I-70 Series (Cardinals vs. Royals). About 240 miles separate these two teams and cities in Missouri. St. Louis has dominated the interleague play between them, leading 78-53. Both teams have peaked at different times throughout the past six decades. The collision of championship play was influenced by manager Whitey Herzog’s style of play. Herzog led the AL Royals through some glory years in the late 1970s, then took control of the Cardinals in the early 1980s building an NL top team. In the 1985 World Series, Whitey’s former and current teams met with Kansas City winning in seven games. The Series was not without its controversy, as first base umpire Don Denkinger missed a crucial call in Game 6. St. Louis won the first rivalry series this year, 2 games to 1.
Battle of Ohio (Reds vs. Guardians). This is another matchup of MLB teams at two ends of a state. Both teams have a long, storied MLB history. Indeed, one can trace the first game between the two franchises to July 2, 1869, when the Cincinnati Red Stockings defeated Forest City, a team in Cleveland. A more recent meeting between the two squads was in 1989 with a pre-season exhibition game played in Columbus, the mid-state capitol. Nowadays, the teams face off in the spring Cactus League, and of course meet in two series during the regular season in interleague play. Cleveland leads the all-time series, 76-62. The Reds swept the Guardians a week ago in Cincinnati.
Lone Star Series (Rangers vs. Astros). I’m pushing the envelope a bit putting this one into the same category as the interleague rivalries above. Yes, any sporting event pitting the Dallas/Ft. Worth area against Houston is a big one in Texas. And oh, by the way, these teams used to be interleague rivals until the Astros moved from the National League to the American League in 2012. But really this is a division rivalry that was placed into Rivalry Weekend. The Astros won a tight series a week ago in taking the weekend matchup 2 games to 1. Get this though, the Rangers maintain the slimmest of leads in the all-time series, 145-144. That’s competitive!
Beltway Series (Orioles vs. Nationals). You need a map of the United States to figure out the origin of this rivalry named after the beltway highways in the Baltimore and D.C. areas. The St. Louis Browns moved to Baltimore in 1952 to become the Orioles. With the AL Senators already in the area, MLB soon approved a move by the Senators to Minnesota to become the Twins. When a replacement franchise, called the Senators, also failed, the team was moved to Arlington, Texas, to become the Rangers. It wasn’t until 2005, when the Expos left Montreal to become the Washington Nationals, that the beltway area had two MLB teams again. The interleague series is relatively new with the Orioles leading 64-55. This is despite the fact that the Nationals swept the Orioles recently, leading to the firing of O’s skipper, Brandon Hyde.
Until next Monday,
your Baseball Bench Çoach